Bill Frieder on Parity, Selecting the Field of 68 and more…


Let me give you some examples of what to expect in a couple of weeks in the NCAA Tournament. Consider the following:

  • Three days after downing Georgetown, Seton Hall loses to Rutgers
  • Colorado beats Cal two days after getting routed at home by Stanford
  • Georgetown loses to the Hall and then beats up a ranked Notre Dame squad 59-41
  • Immediately after beating both San Diego St. and UNLV, New Mexico loses to Colorado St. and TCU
  • Winners of 7 straight at the time, Missouri loses at home to Kansas State (then blows a 19-point second half lead in Lawrence)
  • After losing to Iowa, Wisconsin beats Ohio State in Columbus
  • Michigan takes down Ohio State then loses to Purdue at home

It goes on and on—big wins and bad losses. That’s why when you get to the last four in you could throw 20 names in a hat and draw four out and it would be sufficient. Lots of parity heading into March. Good luck filling out that bracket.

Picking Dance Partners

Now, a few myths on the NCAA selection process. One is let’s not even use the 20-win barometer anymore. No one cares who has 20 wins if 10 of them are against teams that are bad or if a team played 34 games overall. A 20-win season being used to determine if a team makes the NCAA Tournament is like saying 3,000 yards passing is still a milestone in the NFL. Times change…

Second thing is with 37 at-large teams 14 losses is not too many. You might forget that five teams made the field last year with 14 losses. Tennessee, Penn State, Michigan State, Marquette and USC all had 14 losses. Tennessee, Penn State and Michigan State had strength of schedules in the top 15. Marquette had five top-25 RPI wins, while USC had five top-50 wins. So if you have a lot of losses but have a good schedule and piled up some big wins, you have a shot…

Of Bulls and Cats

You really have to root for South Florida and Northwestern. Northwestern’s fighting to get in field for first time, while USF has not been there since 1992 – and in just two appearances all-time, they are 0-2. This is a case where you hope the kids don’t feel the pressure. And you can add Harvard to that mix. Remember this about Harvard… it was the team with the highest RPI left out of the field last year (35). USC got in with a 67 RPI. So there is a good guideline. South Florida closes at Louisville and versus West Virginia. Northwestern’s got Ohio State and then goes to Iowa. Some tough games to clinch a bid.

Life’s a Beach

Keep an eye on Long Beach State trying to go undefeated through the Big West. The 49ers are 14-0 and host UC Irvine (9-16) tonight and then play at a good Cal State Fullerton (17-8) team on Saturday.

Down South and Out West

Don’t be shocked if the Pac-12 ends up with the same amount of teams in as the SEC. The SEC has four teams in the top 25 of the RPI in Kentucky (2), Florida (18), Vanderbilt (23) and Alabama (25).  Next highest RPI? Mississippi State at 66 but it is 6-8 in the league and in a free fall. Meanwhile, the Pac-12 has Cal (36), league-leading Washington (52), Oregon (58), Arizona (70) and Colorado (76). I don’t think any of the other teams in the SEC can win the SEC Tournament. But in the Pac-12, no question that the league could get three teams and then a fourth via the Tournament with no great team. Keep that in the back of your bracket mind and let’s revisit later.

– Bill Frieder

Former Michigan and Arizona State head coach Bill Frieder is an analyst for Westwood One’s coverage of NCAA Basketball. In his weekly blog Boxed Out, Bill scours the box scores to bring you interesting stories from the world of college basketball.


Comments Closed

Comments are closed.

Most Recent NCAA Basketball Posts

Boxed Out 800

Bill Frieder on Miami, Oregon, Indiana and more

27 January 2016 No Comments
This week I want to mention some teams that have a great chance to make the Final Four and maybe haven’t been talked about as much. Hurricane Forecast Let’s start in the ACC, and go way south. There is a lot of talent near South Beach. The Hurricanes beat a…
Read More »
TWITBE 800x497

TWITBE: Georgetown’s JT3, commissioner Val Ackerman and Donny Marshall

21 January 2016 Comments are off for this post.
Guests on the latest installment of This Week in the Big East include Georgetown head coach John Thompson III, Big East commissioner Val Ackerman and Fox Sports and Westwood One analyst Donny Marshall. For comprehensive coverage of the conference, log on to! The hosts for This Week In The BIG EAST…
Read More »
Boxed Out by Bill Frieder

Bill Frieder on Iowa, USC, Washington, the A-10 and more

20 January 2016 Comments are off for this post.
When you do something for the first time in more than 20 years, you can get excited. Iowa, behind Jarrod Uthoff, already beat Michigan State on the road for the first time since 1993 (ending an 18-game losing streak) and the Hawkeyes seem to be poised for an incredible run this year.…
Read More »